8800GT FAIL
Today, I was greeted with my video card failing. Lovely. Apple charged me an arm and a leg for the card back in May or June of 2008. It didn’t make it 2 years without causing me problems. Funny thing is, the card that shipped with the machine (7300GT w/256mb VRAM) seems to perform as well as the 8800gt has for some time, which leads me to believe that it has been failing for a long time.
I pulled the card out, after both OSX and Windows 7 froze up. OSX actually seemed to push the hardware to the point where it showed lots of artifacts on the screen. I then pulled the card, took off the heatsink, removed all the old thermal paste, and applied some good Arctic Silver 5. I put it all back together, plopped it into the machine, and found that the damage was already done.
Now, with the 7300gt back in, I can see a lot of things were going wrong with the 8800 for a while – specifically, the text on the screen in certain places (both 2d and 3d) is more crisp. The framerates in World of Warcraft were about the same as with the 8800 – 24 to 36 or so.
I found that the fan on the GPU had a missing blade, which explains why the card seemed to be very loud. The problem I have is that it was ALWAYS loud, which makes me wonder if the card was defective from Apple.
In any case, I read up on what most other Mac Pro 1,1 owners are doing in terms of graphics card upgrades, and found that people are taking PC cards, and flashing the BIOS over to the Mac-compatible EFI. I then picked up the needed parts – another power cable for the card, from ATI, and a new ATI Radeon HD4870 w/1gb VRAM. ATI FlashTool is a godsend, as it will make it possible to easily flash the card over to the Mac EFI bios. Overall, I guess it was time for an upgrade (the radeon is dx10.1 w/1gb, while the 8800 was dx10.0 w/512mb). All in all, time will tell whether it was worth fixing this machine or not.